Customer-led vs product-led growth: which is right for your SaaS?

For SaaS companies, growth strategies often dictate the trajectory of success. Two dominant paradigms - customer-led growth (CLG) and product-led growth (PLG) - present contrasting paths for scaling businesses. While CLG emphasizes listening to and evolving with your customers’ needs, PLG prioritizes product usability and customer self-service as the engine for expansion. Understanding these approaches and determining which fits your SaaS company best is pivotal for sustainable growth.

In this article, we’ll explore the nuances of CLG and PLG, compare their strengths and challenges, and provide actionable advice for selecting and implementing the best strategy for your SaaS business.

Understanding customer-led growth (CLG)

The principles of CLG

Customer-led growth revolves around deeply understanding your users and tailoring solutions to meet their evolving needs. Companies utilizing CLG prioritize:

• Customer feedback loops: Continuous collection and integration of feedback to refine offerings.
• Iterative product development: Adjusting products based on customer pain points and aspirations.
• Proactive support and relationship building: Ensuring customer satisfaction translates to loyalty.

For example, Zendesk is known for its customer-centric philosophy and revamped its offerings by analyzing customer interactions. A key change included tailoring enterprise-level features, after feedback showed that SMB solutions no longer met larger customers’ demands.

Source: https://www.dashly.io/blog/customer-led-growth/

Benefits of customer-led growth

High customer loyalty

When companies actively listen to their customers and adapt their offerings accordingly, it fosters a sense of trust and belonging. Customers who feel valued are more likely to stay loyal to a brand over the long term. 

A study by Deloitte and Touche notably found that customer-centric companies are 60% more profitable compared to those that are not. 

Better alignment with market needs

By closely aligning product development with customer feedback, businesses can significantly reduce the risk of creating features that lack market demand. 

For instance, Atlassian, the company behind Jira, developed several of its features by listening to users in its forums and conducting user testing sessions. This approach has contributed to their $2 billion annual revenue. Research by PwC supports this, noting that 73% of all consumers point to customer experience as an important factor in their purchasing decisions.

Organic referrals

Satisfied customers often become brand advocates, sharing their positive experiences through word-of-mouth, social media, and reviews. This phenomenon especially impacts SaaS businesses, where trust and reliability are critical. Dropbox, for example, utilized this principle by introducing a referral program rewarding customers with additional storage for inviting friends, leading to a 60% increase in signups. 

Studies show that 92% of people trust recommendations from friends and family more than any other form of marketing. 

Challenges of customer-led growth

However, CLG poses challenges like slower iteration due to the need to gather and act on customer feedback, which can delay go-to-market timelines in fast-paced industries. While this ensures products better align with customer needs, it can hinder agility in competitive markets.

CLG is also resource-intensive, requiring dedicated teams for customer research and support. Smaller SaaS companies may struggle to allocate the necessary manpower or budget, making it difficult to maintain effective feedback loops. Moreover, there’s a risk of over-customization. Focusing too much on individual requests can dilute the product’s vision. 

📌 TL;DR - CLG focuses on understanding and adapting to customer needs, fostering loyalty and aligning products with market demand. SaaS companies can thrive by leveraging customer feedback. However, CLG can be resource-intensive, slow down iteration, and risk over-customization if not managed carefully.

Unpacking product-led growth (PLG)

Product-led growth hinges on letting the product itself drive customer acquisition, activation, and retention. Key elements include:

• Intuitive user experience (UX): Products should deliver immediate value with minimal onboarding, ensuring users can quickly grasp key features without extensive guidance or training.
• Freemium models: Offering a free version encourages users to explore core features and build trust, making it easier for them to transition to paid plans once they recognize the product's value.
• Data-driven design: Continuously refining the product by analyzing user interaction data helps address pain points, improve engagement, and ensure the product evolves in line with customer needs.

As an example, Slack’s frictionless sign-up and free-tier model made it a staple for team collaboration. Users naturally upgraded to paid plans as their teams expanded.

Source: https://www.aha.io/roadmapping/guide/what-is-product-led-growth

Advantages of product-led growth

Scalability

PLG models are inherently scalable because they automate key stages of the customer journey, such as onboarding, product adoption, and upselling. By enabling users to self-serve and explore the product independently, PLG significantly reduces the need for large, costly sales teams. 

Instead of relying on manual outreach, PLG leverages intuitive design, in-app guidance, and automated nurturing campaigns to convert users. This scalability allows PLG companies to handle surges in demand effortlessly, ensuring smooth growth without the proportional increase in headcount, making them more cost-efficient compared to traditional sales-led models​.

Faster user acquisition

By offering freemium and self-serve options, PLG eliminates many of the barriers to entry for new users, allowing them to experience the product’s value without a significant upfront commitment. For instance, Zoom’s freemium model played a crucial role in its rapid adoption, especially during the pandemic, where its user base grew by 354% in a single year. 

You can learn more about freemium models by reading our article here.

Focus on product excellence

PLG emphasizes creating a superior product experience, encouraging companies to continuously invest in improving their core offerings. According to a study by Userpilot, SaaS companies that prioritize product excellence experience 15% higher customer satisfaction and retention rates. This focus ensures the product speaks for itself and drives growth organically.

Drawbacks of product-led growth

PLG strategies require a significant upfront investment to develop an intuitive, feature-rich product that delivers immediate value. This poses a challenge for startups with limited resources or funding. A CB Insights report highlights that 42% of startups fail because they underestimate the resources needed to build scalable products, underscoring the financial risks of PLG.

PLG’s success often hinges on virality - users discovering and sharing the product independently. While this can drive rapid growth, it’s risky if the product lacks unique features or a strong network effect. Even Slack, a PLG success story, relied heavily on word-of-mouth, emphasizing the need for constant innovation to sustain momentum.

Additionally, PLG’s standardized approach may alienate niche markets that require tailored solutions or high-touch support. Enterprise clients, for example, often need custom integrations, which a pure PLG model may struggle to offer. 

📌 TL;DR - PLG focuses on the product driving user acquisition, adoption, and retention through intuitive design, freemium models, and data-driven improvements. It’s scalable, cost-efficient, and accelerates user acquisition by lowering entry barriers. However, PLG demands significant upfront investment, relies on virality, and may struggle with personalization for niche markets or enterprise clients.

Comparing CLG and PLG

Alignment with business goals

When aligning CLG and PLG with business goals, key differences emerge. CLG’s personalized approach often leads to higher customer lifetime value (CLV) through tailored support, while PLG’s scalability drives faster top-line growth by automating customer acquisition. 

In competitive markets, CLG excels by fostering loyalty and differentiation, whereas PLG is most effective when a product has broad appeal. This allows for rapid user growth without relying heavily on sales efforts.

Resource considerations

Resource considerations also influence the choice of strategy. CLG works best for companies with strong customer success teams and budgets for qualitative research to create personalized experiences. 

In contrast, PLG benefits startups with limited sales resources but strong product development expertise, allowing them to scale by creating a product that sells itself.

Hybrid approaches

Some SaaS companies blend these models. According to insights from Growth Unhinged, successful PLG companies like ClickUp leverage a hybrid approach, combining PLG with sales-assist strategies to optimize growth. 

ClickUp’s COO highlighted how these methods helped reduce customer acquisition costs while maintaining scalability by automating key interactions and selectively involving sales for high-value conversions. 

This model demonstrates how PLG companies can achieve rapid growth by blending automation with targeted human engagement, a strategy increasingly adopted across the SaaS industry.​

Choosing the right strategy

Here are a few steps to identify the best fit for your company:

1. Assess your product’s maturity: Early-stage startups with limited features benefit from CLG to refine their product. Mature products with strong functionality can scale faster through PLG.
   
2. Evaluate your customer base: CLG suits large enterprises that need customization and support, while PLG works better for SMBs and individual users who prefer simplicity and low commitment.
   
3. Analyze key metrics: Review metrics like NPS, churn rates, and acquisition costs. If customer feedback is vital to retention, CLG may be ideal, as it emphasizes personalized engagement.

💡Common pitfalls to avoid:

• Failing to align strategy with customer expectations.
• Over-relying on freemium without clear upgrade paths (PLG).
• Neglecting customer feedback in pursuit of scalability (PLG).

Conclusion

Both customer-led and product-led growth strategies offer distinct advantages for SaaS companies. CLG builds deep, loyal relationships that are ideal for complex products and enterprise clients. PLG drives rapid, cost-effective scalability, suiting straightforward and widely appealing solutions. The optimal choice often depends on your product’s maturity, target audience, and available resources.

You can implement a growth strategy that ensures long-term success by carefully evaluating your business goals and customer needs. And for many SaaS businesses, a hybrid approach that draws on the strengths of both models may prove the most effective path forward.

{{newsletter}}